医学教育管理 ›› 2026, Vol. 12 ›› Issue (5): 664-671.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.2096-045X.2026.05.014

• 调查研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

心外ICU进修医生教学需求与满意度调查分析

  

  1. 首都医科大学附属北京安贞医院心外危重症中心,北京 100029
  • 收稿日期:2026-04-01 修回日期:2026-04-09 出版日期:2026-11-13 发布日期:2026-11-13

Survey and analysis of teaching needs and satisfaction of visiting physicians in Center for Cardiac Intensive Care

  1. Department of Intensive Care Unit, Beijing Anzhen Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing 100029, China
  • Received:2026-04-01 Revised:2026-04-09 Online:2026-11-13 Published:2026-11-13

摘要:

目的 调查心外科重症监护室(intensive care unit,ICU)进修医生的教学需求与满意度,分析不同特征进修医生教学需求的差异,为优化培训方案提供依据。方法 采用便利抽样法,选取2019年1月至2025年12月在首都医科大学附属北京安贞医院心外ICU进修的53名医生为研究对象。自行设计《心外ICU进修医生教学需求与满意度调查问卷》,通过问卷星进行匿名调查,采用Likert 5级评分。使用SPSS 26.0进行统计分析,信度采用Cronbach’s α系数检验,效度采用探索性因子分析。为控制不同进修年份可能带来的培训方案变动偏倚,将“进修年份”作为协变量纳入分析,采用协方差分析比较不同特征进修医生教学需求的差异,组间两两比较采用LSD法。结果 回收有效问卷53份,有效回收率100%。问卷信效度良好。操作技能的需求得分最高(4.52±0.53),理论知识次之(4.47±0.50),综合能力需求相对较低(3.93±0.62)。在教学满意度方面,总体满意度得分为(4.18±0.56)分,各维度得分从高到低依次为师资带教(4.36±0.51)、实践机会(4.21±0.58)、整体收获(4.19±0.54)、课程设置(4.08±0.62)、教学方法(4.03±0.67)。控制进修年份后,不同特征进修医生教学需求分析显示,低年资进修医生对基础理论(F=5.482,P=0.022)和基础技能(F=6.593,P=0.012)的需求显著高于高年资医生;来自二级医院的进修医生对基础技能(F=9.761,P=0.002)和综合能力(F=4.068,P=0.047)的需求显著高于三级医院医生;既往无ICU工作经历的进修医生在基础理论(F=8.369,P=0.005)和基础技能(F=11.641,P=0.001)方面的需求均显著高于有ICU经历者。不同职称组在基础理论和基础技能需求上差异有统计学意义(P<0.05),LSD两两比较显示住院医师需求显著高于副主任医师及以上(P<0.05)。进修年份作为协变量对各维度需求均无显著影响(P>0.05)。开放性问题显示,进修医生最希望增加的培训内容是ECMO模拟演练(68.3%)、重症超声手把手教学(62.2%)和疑难病例讨论(57.3%)。结论 心外ICU进修医生对机械循环辅助设备管理和高级血流动力学监测等高阶知识与技能需求迫切,但对科研思维、教学能力等综合能力重视不足。教学满意度总体良好,但教学方法的创新性和课程设置的针对性有待提升。综上应根据进修医生背景差异实施分层教学,重点加强模拟培训和重症超声实践,同时引导学员重视综合能力培养。

关键词:

"> 心外ICU|进修医生|教学需求|满意度|问卷调查

Abstract:

Objective  To investigate the teaching needs and satisfaction of visiting physicians in the Center for Cardiac Intensive Care (CCIC), analyze the differences in teaching needs among visiting physicians with different characteristics, and provide a basis for optimizing the training program. Methods A convenience sampling method was used to select 53 visiting physicians who received traininng in the CCIC of Beijing Anzhen Hospital, Capital Medical University, from January 2019 to December 2025 as the study subjects. A self-designed "Questionnaire on Teaching Needs and Satisfaction of Visiting Physicians in CCIC" was used for an anonymous survey via the Wenjuanxing platform, employing a Likert 5-level scale. SPSS 26.0 was used for statistical analysis. Reliability was tested using Cronbach’s α coefficient, and validity was tested using exploratory factor analysis. To control for bias caused by changes in training programmes across different advanced training years, "year of advanced training" was included in the analysis as a covariate. Analysis of covariance was used to compare differences in teaching needs among advanced training physicians with different characteristics, and the LSD method was applied for pairwise comparisons between groups. Results A total of 53 valid questionnaires were collected, with an effective response rate of 100%. The questionnaire demonstrated good reliability and validity. Operational skills had the highest demand score (4.52±0.53), followed by theoretical knowledge (4.47±0.50), while the demand for comprehensive abilities was relatively lower (3.93±0.62). Regarding teaching satisfaction, the overall satisfaction score was 4.18±0.56. Scores for dimensions from highest to lowest were: faculty teaching (4.36±0.51), practical opportunities (4.21±0.58), overall gains (4.19±0.54), curriculum design (4.08±0.62), and teaching methods (4.03±0.67). After controlling for the year of training, analysis of teaching needs among visiting physicians with different characteristics showed that junior visiting physicians had significantly higher demand for basic theory (F=5.482, P=0.022) and basic skills (F=6.593, P=0.012) compared with senior physicians. Physicians from secondary hospitals had significantly higher demand for basic skills (F=9.761, P=0.002) and comprehensive abilities (F=4.068, P=0.047) than those from tertiary hospitals. Physicians without prior ICU work experience had significantly higher demand for basic theory (F=8.369, P=0.005) and basic skills (F=11.641, P=0.001) compared with those with ICU experience. Significant differences were found in basic theory and basic skills among different professional title groups (P<0.05), with LSD pairwise comparisons showing that residents had significantly higher demand than associate chief physicians and above (P<0.05). The covariate “year of training” had no significant effect on any dimension of teaching needs (P>0.05). Open-ended questions revealed that the training contents visiting physicians most desired to add were ECMO simulation drills (68.3%), hands-on teaching of critical care ultrasound (62.2%), and difficult case discussions (57.3%). Conclusion Visiting physicians in the CCIC have a strong demand for advanced knowledge and skills, such as mechanical circulatory support device management and advanced hemodynamic monitoring, but place insufficient emphasis on comprehensive abilities like scientific research thinking and teaching skills. Overall teaching satisfaction is good, but the innovation of teaching methods and the specificity of curriculum design need improvement. Stratified teaching should be implemented based on the diverse backgrounds of visiting physicians, with a focus on strengthening simulation training and critical care ultrasound practice, while guiding them to value the development of comprehensive abilities.

Key words:

"> center for cardiac intensive care|visiting physicians| teaching needs| satisfaction|questionnaire survey